Alexandra Holzer	Self - Paranormal Investigator
Carol Beamer	Self - Friend of Dawn DeFeo
Carol Soviero	Self - Lutz Family Friend
Christopher Lutz	Self
Christopher Quaratino	Self
Ellen Stark	Self - Author, Daughter of Judge Thomas Stark
Erik Davis	Self - Author & Cultural Scholar
Gloria Gangitano	Self - DeFeo Family Friend
Joe Vetter	Self - Friend of George Lutz
Joel Martin	Self - News Director, WBAB Radio

Laura DiDio	Self - Investigative Reporter
Marvin Scott	Self
Michael Race	Self - Ret. Homicide Detective
Paula Uruburu	Self - Friend of Dawn DeFeo
Tommy Maher	Self - Friend of Ronnie DeFeo Jr.

Amityville: An Origin Story egyéb:

Amityville: An Origin Story